Leaving through a different door from the one used to enter is traditionally treated as unlucky in several documented folk-belief records. The most stable part of the belief is the route itself: a visitor enters through one doorway and is expected to leave through that same doorway. What supposedly happens if the rule is broken varies. Historical records mention personal bad luck, trouble for the household, loss of the house’s good fortune, failure to return, or the arrival of more visitors.
There is no well-supported single origin for the superstition. A New Orleans record published by Lafcadio Hearn in 1886 describes leaving by another door as carrying away the good luck of the place, while Hearn also cautions that the belief was widely distributed and should not be treated as uniquely Creole. [1]
What Is Supposed to Happen If You Leave by Another Door?
The answer depends on the record. The superstition does not carry one fixed consequence across every place or family.
| Recorded Context | Leaving Through Another Door Is Said To… |
|---|---|
| New Orleans, published 1886 | Carry away the good luck of the place. [1] |
| Pennsylvania, published 1896 | Bring trouble with the family or bad luck to the visitor. [2] |
| Cumberland, Maine, published 1896 | Mean that the visitor will not come again. [2] |
| Warwickshire example recorded in a British folklore study | Carry a warning that the person may never set foot in the house again. [3] |
| Detroit folklore records | Bring bad luck, affect both visitor and household, or foretell more company, depending on the telling. [4] |
The differences matter. “Bad luck” is common, but it is not the only documented meaning. Some versions protect the visitor, some focus on the household, and others turn the act into an omen about future visits.
The Same-Door Rule in Historical Records
Fanny D. Bergen’s 1896 collection Current Superstitions preserves two especially clear American examples. The Pennsylvania entry says a person must leave through the door used to enter or face family trouble or personal ill luck. The following entry, attributed to Cumberland, Maine, changes the consequence: leaving through another door means the person will not come again. [2]
The belief also appears in twentieth-century documentation from the British Isles. In J. D. A. Widdowson’s 1972 discussion of house traditions, visitors are described as sometimes being directed back toward the doorway through which they entered. The Warwickshire wording preserved there links a different exit with not returning to the house. [3]
An Observed Irish Example
A record in Ireland’s National Folklore Collection gives a particularly useful example because it describes behavior rather than simply listing a saying. During a visit on Inishbofin, County Galway, the recorder was about to depart through a different doorway when the woman of the house stopped the visitor and directed them back to the entrance used on arrival. The accompanying explanation states that the same door should serve for both entering and leaving on that occasion. [5]
Some Versions Change the Rule
The University of Detroit Mercy’s James T. Callow Folklore Archive preserves several forms collected in the 1960s and 1970s. Together they show how easily the belief changes in oral transmission.
- One Detroit record says leaving by a different door brings bad luck to both the visitor and the people living in the home.
- Other Detroit records say using another exit means more company will come.
- One version warns against entering the front door and immediately leaving through another door without first sitting down. In that telling, sitting inside changes the condition of the rule.
- A Pittsburgh record extends the same-door practice beyond houses: the informant’s grandmother reportedly observed it even in stores.
- An Arkansas record from 1973 gives the familiar form that any exit other than the original entrance brings bad luck. [4]
There are even reversed versions. The Callow archive contains records from Cornersville and Nashville, Tennessee, in which leaving through the same door is described as unlucky. That contradiction is useful evidence of folklore variation rather than a problem to be corrected. [4]
Why Is the Door Important?
Historical explanations are much less consistent than the rule itself. Widdowson describes the doorway as the dividing point between the house and the outside and notes that greeting, admission, and leave-taking often take place there. That helps explain why doors attract household customs and beliefs, but it does not prove that this particular superstition began from one symbolic idea. [3]
Some recorded explanations are highly local or family-specific. A 2014 entry in the USC Digital Folklore Archives records one family account described by the informant as Greek: entering through one door and leaving through another was said to tangle the “string” of a person’s life. This is evidence for that particular telling, not evidence that all Greek communities share the explanation or that it represents the historical origin of the wider superstition. [6]
Is Leaving Through a Different Door Actually Bad Luck?
No factual evidence shows that choosing a different doorway changes a person’s luck. The rule belongs to documented folklore. Its value as a record lies in the ways families and communities have remembered, explained, altered, and practiced it.
What Can Be Said About Its Origin?
The surviving evidence supports an old and geographically dispersed household belief, but not a single proven birthplace. By 1886 Hearn was already describing the rule as widely spread rather than assigning it a secure local origin. American collections soon documented related forms in Pennsylvania and Maine, while later British, Irish, and American archives preserved additional versions. [1]
Claims that the superstition definitively began in one country, one ethnic tradition, or one ancient religious practice therefore go beyond the records used here. The evidence is better read as a family of related beliefs built around a simple action: return through the doorway that marked your arrival.
Sources and Records
- ↑1a ↑1b ↑1c Lafcadio Hearn, “New Orleans Superstitions”,
- ↑2a ↑2b ↑2c Fanny D. Bergen, ed., Current Superstitions: Collected from the Oral Tradition of English Speaking Folk,
- ↑3a ↑3b ↑3c J. D. A. Widdowson, “Traditions of the House and Home”,
- ↑4a ↑4b ↑4c University of Detroit Mercy Libraries, James T. Callow Computerized Folklore Archive, entrance and exit records,
- ↑5 National Folklore Collection, UCD, “Superstition,” Main Manuscript Collection, Volume 0838, p. 470,
- ↑6 USC Digital Folklore Archives, “Greek Traditions: Entering and Exiting a Building”,
Documented Locations
Countries: Canada
Regions: Newfoundland (Canada)
These labels identify where a version has been documented. They do not mean that everyone in the country, region, or community shares the belief.
